The least bobbly of the three garments I pulled out for this article cost me £8.
It is a muted rust cotton crew-neck jumper from a charity shop, about two years old, with a surface that still looks remarkably clean from ordinary standing distance. Its left side seam has also wandered several centimetres towards the front and the hem no longer hangs quite level. If pilling were a complete quality test, this thing would be winning.
The most expensive is a dark bottle-green cashmere jumper I bought new in an end-of-season sale for £110. It has done five winters. The ribbing is still good, the shape still works and I still want to wear it. It also has fine pills beneath the arms and along the sides. I noticed more of them during its first couple of winters than I do now, and I have combed the surface lightly on a few occasions.
The third garment is not a jumper at all. It is the deep plum polyester-viscose shirt I bought on Vinted for £11 plus postage, and it is here because it has the most useful history. I have already taken a debobbler to it once. The surface improved. After more wear, some of the bobbling came back.
Continue reading








